With all of the roofing projects we do, there are always complexities we have to take into consideration. But with this particular residential roofing job, there were quite a few moving parts, hurdles and issues that we had to overcome. The minute we stepped foot on the property to survey the situation, we knew the roof would need to be completely replaced because we could see that it was curling everywhere. However, we hit a bit of a snag. The existing slate brand and model were discontinued years before, and there were numerous claims of defective roofs that the manufacturer settled with a class action lawsuit. Not a problem. Not so fast. The next issue was product availability. Once you order a product, there’s quite a long turnaround time, but we figured we needed to get started tearing off the old roof before the product arrived due to its sheer size. But there was one thing hanging over our heads: crazy Dallas weather. Since PEAK is Texas-owned and we’ve seen a thing or two through the decades, we understood this schizoid dynamic. Luckily, we beat the rain and the materials arrived just when we were ready for them so it all worked out. Perfect timing.
But here’s where other companies might’ve lost their footing. The roof had dangerously steep slopes with multiple conical turrets, upwards of 24/12 pitch, which meant that you get 24 inches of rise every 12 inches. So most of our work had to be done with everybody strapped in with ropes and harnesses. The client was buying the house and wouldn’t complete the deal until the roof was replaced. They also asked that we put together a day-by-day detailed schedule and expected us to follow this as closely as possible. We always do that, but in this case, the client was on an accelerated schedule because he was leaving the country. So a job that would normally take three or four weeks had to be completed in two weeks. We devised a plan we knew would work and kicked it into high gear.
We replaced the roof in sections, facet by facet, quadrant by quadrant, methodically and with utter finesse. After everything was completed, we fabricated and installed almost 1,000 linear feet of oversized six-inch gutters with matching downspouts to match the roof. After all, was said and done, everyone was walking on air. Time may be running out to take full advantage of your existing warranty. DaVinci's warranty coverage steps down after year 10. DaVinci Roofscapes, one of the industry's most respected manufacturers of composite roofing systems, officially discontinued its Bellaforte line in May 2023 after homeowners and contractors began noticing cracking at the shingle tabs in certain conditions. These cracks can spread over time, leading to leaks, interior water damage, and - in some cases - premature roof replacement.
We still believe in and install DaVinci Roofscapes products, and we stand behind them as always. DaVinci's warranty coverage declines after 10 years. 100% of our recommended warranty claims have been approved. What we look for The damage we find on Bellaforte roofs. From the ground, most Bellaforte roofs look perfect. Up close, the same patterns of tab cracking show up again and again. A dark fracture opening at the corner of a tab - the signature Bellaforte failure. A crack running clean through the shingle. We give Bill O'Connor five stars PLUS!! He helped us navigate our claim for DaVinci shingle replacement from start to finish (we were clueless as to where to begin). He is very nice to deal with… answers texts right away with any questions. And his crew did an amazing job with our roof!! Not a small job and it was completed in four days.
Why we contacted you We installed Bellaforte Slate roofs across Omaha during wood-shake replacement projects in the 2010s. At the time, it was considered a premium composite system that met even strict HOA requirements. Long-term performance has since revealed unexpected challenges with the shingle's design. We've already walked our earliest affected customers through the DaVinci claim process. We won't tell you there's an issue if there isn't. ORDER OF DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE (see Order for specifics). Signed by Honorable Timothy L. Brooks on May 6, 2022. NOTICE of Appearance by Brian A Brown on behalf of Nationwide General Insurance Company. NOTICE of Appearance by Brian A Brown on behalf of Nationwide General Insurance Company.
ORDER Setting Hearings: Settlement Conference set for 6/16/2022 09:00 AM in Fayetteville - 2nd flr (Rm 210) before Honorable Christy D. Comstock. Signed by Honorable Christy D. Comstock on January 4, 2022. CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER: Final Pretrial Conference set for 8/12/2022 09:00 AM in Fayetteville -- 5th flr (Rm 509) before Honorable Timothy L. Brooks. JURY TRIAL set for 8/22/2022 09:00 AM in Fayetteville -- 5th flr (Rm 509) before Honorable Timothy L. Brooks. Signed by Honorable Timothy L. Brooks on December 22, 2021.
The document excerpts and related notices describe complex legal and warranty contexts surrounding the Bellaforte Slate and related DaVinci Roofscapes products. The material defect involves small tabs that were intended to be nailed and later weakened, creating tears and widespread shingle damage over time. Homeowners have interactions with warranty processes, claims representatives, and settlement procedures as part of addressing these defects. Despite discontinuation and known issues, the installation team continues to support DaVinci products and advocates proactive warranty engagement to safeguard homeowners’ interests.
Key practical takeaways from the case
- Assess roof condition early to determine whether a full replacement is necessary, especially when curling or significant wear is evident.
- Document product availability constraints and weather impacts to inform scheduling and safety planning for steep, complex roofs.
- Prepare a detailed day-by-day schedule when clients request accelerated timelines, and plan work in sections to maintain control over progress.
- Understand warranty terms and potential declines after a decade, and communicate clearly with manufacturers and insurers during the claim process.
- Implement safety measures for high-slope or conical turret designs, including rope and harness protocols for worker and client safety.
- Plan and execute sectional replacements to manage risk and weather windows.
- Fabricate and install ancillary systems (e.g., oversized gutters) to ensure a cohesive finish with the main roof replacement.
- Stay engaged with warranty claim processes, ensuring that homeowners receive appropriate materials and labor coverage when defects are acknowledged.
In short, the DaVinci Bellaforte slate case illustrates how a combination of product discontinuation, documented defects, weather constraints, and urgent client expectations can shape a residential roof replacement strategy. The approach in this project balanced safety, schedule, and warranty considerations while delivering a high-quality outcome for the homeowner.

Table: Project timeline and outcomes
| Phase | Details | Duration |
|---|---|---|
| Survey and decision | Assessment; replacement required due to curling; discontinued slate issue | 1 day |
| Material planning | Order slate; long lead times; weather considerations | 2-3 days |
| Site execution | Section-by-section replacement; safety protocols for 24/12 pitch | 2 weeks |
| Gutter installation | Almost 1,000 linear feet of six-inch gutters | 4 days |
| Warranty and claims | DaVinci eligibility; claims processed; warranty terms noted |
Time may be running out to take full advantage of your existing warranty. DaVinci's warranty coverage steps down after year 10. DaVinci Roofscapes, one of the industry's most respected manufacturers of composite roofing systems, officially discontinued its Bellaforte line in May 2023 after homeowners and contractors began noticing cracking at the shingle tabs in certain conditions. These cracks can spread over time, leading to leaks, interior water damage, and - in some cases - premature roof replacement. We still believe in and install DaVinci Roofscapes products, and we stand behind them as always. DaVinci's warranty coverage declines after 10 years. 100% of our recommended warranty claims have been approved.